6 Best Percolator Filters (October 2026) Buying Guide

The best percolator filter depends on your pot, but the MIMORE unbleached wrap-around pack is the strongest all-round pick here for small stovetop and electric percolators, especially Farberware 4-cup models. A percolator filter is a disposable paper insert that sits in or around the metal basket to hold back grounds and fine sediment, so the cup comes out cleaner than a bare basket allows. For larger electric pots, the 200-piece pack made for Presto 12-cup percolators is the better fit, and the 300-piece disc pack is the pick for people who brew daily. Always match the filter to your basket before buying in bulk.

Quick List

• Farberware-style 150-piece perforated filters – best for 4-cup and 6-cup percolators named in the listing
• Presto-style 200-piece perforated wavy filters – best for 12-cup electric percolators and 10-cup Moss and Stone style pots
• 300-piece 3.75-inch unbleached discs – best for daily brewers who want the largest count
• Melitta Super Premium Disc filters (100 count) – best for those who prefer a familiar white brand-name disc
• MIMORE 150-piece wrap-around filters – best overall for small Farberware percolators and wrap-style fit
• Brew Rite Wrap Around filters (2 packs of 55) – best for occasional use and for travel or camp pots

Which One Is Right for You?

Basket shape matters more than brand. A disc sits flat under the stem and over the holes, while a wrap-around filter folds up the stem and sides. If you do not know which style your pot uses, measure the basket and look at the stem before you order.

All 6 Picks in Detail

1. Farberware-Style 150-Piece Perforated Filters – Best for Small Pots Named in the Listing

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

#1 Pick

150 Pcs Perforated Coffee Filters for Farberware Coffee Percolator 4 Cup | Percolator Coffee Filters for Coletti 6 Cup, Elite Gourmet 6 Cup,

Check Price on Amazon →

This pack is sold as perforated percolator filters for the Farberware 4-cup percolator, and the title extends the fit to Coletti 6-cup and Elite Gourmet 6-cup models among others. That long compatibility list is the main value: it tells you the seller expects the filter to suit baskets in the small-to-medium range. Perforated means pre-punched with holes so water can pass while paper traps fines. The listing name does not say whether the shape is a disc or a wrap-around, so confirm on the product page, because that decides how it sits on the stem.

Because it is a 150-count pack, it covers about five months of a once-a-day habit before you reorder. Keep the pack sealed in a dry drawer, since loose paper absorbs kitchen humidity and odors.

• Count: 150 pieces
• Style: perforated; disc or wrap-around is not stated, so confirm on listing
• Named fits: Farberware 4-cup, Coletti 6-cup, Elite Gourmet 6-cup
• Material: confirm on the listing
• Use: disposable, one brew per filter

If your pot is a Farberware 4-cup, this is where the fit discussion starts, because small stovetop and electric models have narrow baskets that leave little room for error. Read the product page photos for the hole pattern and the center cutout, and compare them to the basket you own.

Pros:

• Clear model list helps you check fit
• Generous count for the size of pot

Cons:

• Shape is not clear from the title
• Not intended for larger 12-cup baskets

Compared with the MIMORE pack, it targets the same pots but leaves the shape question open.

2. Presto-Style 200-Piece Perforated Wavy Filters – Best for 12-Cup Electric Percolators

#2 Pick

Percolator Coffee Filters for Presto Coffee Percolator Electric 12 Cup | 200 Pcs, Perforated Wavy Design, Filter Paper for Moss & Stone 10 C

Check Price on Amazon →

This is the pack to consider if you use a Presto 12-cup electric percolator, which the title names directly, along with a Moss and Stone 10-cup style pot. The perforated wavy design is described as filter paper for those baskets, and the 200-piece count gives you a long supply for a big pot that gets used for gatherings. Large percolators have bigger baskets and more grounds, so a filter that is too small or too thin tears and lets sediment through.

The listing does not state a diameter, so check the basket size in your manual against the product description before you commit to a pack this large. Brewing a full 12 cups also means a heavy basket, so a sturdy paper is worth more than a pretty one.

• Count: 200 pieces
• Named fits: Presto 12-cup electric percolator, Moss and Stone 10-cup
• Design: perforated, wavy edge per the title
• Diameter: confirm on listing
• Use: disposable, one brew per filter

Large percolators also tend to brew hotter and longer, which stresses thin paper. If you plan to fill the basket near the top for a crowd, choose the sturdiest sheet you can and avoid tamping the grounds down, since compacted grounds slow water and can overflow the basket.

Pros:

• Named for a popular large electric pot
• Large count suits frequent hosts

Cons:

• Diameter is not stated in the title
• Too big for small stovetop baskets

It sits at the other end of the size range from the Farberware-style pack, so choose by pot size first.

3. 300-Piece 3.75-Inch Unbleached Disc Filters – Best for Daily Brewers

#3 Pick

300Pcs Percolator Coffee Filter, 3.75in Unbleached Disposable Coffee Filter | Natural Wood Pulp, Tear Resistant, Fits 3.75in Percolator Coff

Check Price on Amazon →

This pack is the value pick by count: 300 unbleached discs made of natural wood pulp, described as tear-resistant and sized at 3.75 inches. A disc this size suits percolator baskets with a matching bottom diameter, so measure the flat base of your basket first. Unbleached paper has a brownish tint and, per the listing, no chlorine bleaching, which some buyers prefer. A disc has a center opening or is punched for the stem, so check how it seats on your model.

Three hundred filters is a lot to store, so keep them flat and dry. If you share a pot with a camper or cabin, the count also covers a full season of weekends.

• Count: 300 pieces
• Diameter: 3.75 inches per the title
• Material: unbleached natural wood pulp
• Style: flat disc
• Strength: described as tear resistant

Its natural wood pulp wording and tear resistance suggest a heavier sheet than a basic disc, though the listing gives no thickness figure, so the claim stays a seller description. For a group that brews every morning, a heavier disc that survives a firm stem is worth more than a thin one.

Pros:

• Largest count in the group
• Stated diameter makes fit easy to check

Cons:

• Only fits baskets that match 3.75 inches
• No wrap-around side coverage

Next to the Melitta discs, it offers triple the count in an unbleached finish but less brand reassurance.

4. Melitta Super Premium Disc Coffee Filters – Best Familiar White Disc

#4 Pick

Melitta Super Premium Disc Coffee Filters, White, 100 Count (Pack of 1)

Check Price on Amazon →

Melitta is a long-established filter maker, and this pack contains 100 white discs sold as Super Premium. The listing name does not state a diameter or a percolator model, so it is a fit-check purchase: Melitta sells disc filters in several sizes, and some are cut for percolator baskets, so confirm the diameter on the product page against your basket. If it matches, white paper is a clean-looking option that many shoppers already trust.

White filters are usually bleached, so check the packaging if that matters to you. The 100-count pack suits a household that brews a few times a week.

• Count: 100 pieces
• Style: disc, per the product line
• Color: white
• Diameter: confirm on listing
• Fit: no percolator model named, so confirm

A sensible approach is to look up your percolator model on Melitta’s product pages or in your manual and see whether a disc size is recommended. If the numbers line up, you gain a familiar filter; if they do not, the other discs here have clearer fit statements.

Pros:

• Recognizable brand
• Moderate pack size

Cons:

• Fit information is thin in the listing name
• Fewer filters per pack than the others

It is the brand-name alternative to the 300-piece unbleached disc pack, with the same shape but a smaller count.

5. MIMORE Wrap-Around Percolator Filters (150) – Best Overall for Small Farberware Pots

#5 Pick

MIMORE Percolator Coffee Filters for Farberware 4-Cup, Unbleached, 150 PCS | Balanced Thickness, No Paper Taste, Wrap Around, Disposable, fo

Check Price on Amazon →

MIMORE sells these as unbleached, disposable, wrap-around percolator filters for Farberware 4-cup pots, with a 150-piece count. The title promises balanced thickness and no paper taste, which are claims about feel and flavor rather than measured results. A wrap-around design folds around the stem and up the basket wall, giving you coverage on the sides as well as the base, which helps when you pack grounds high.

That coverage is why we place it first for small pots: grounds that escape from the sides of a basket are the usual source of grit in a percolator cup. Check that your pot is a 4-cup model like the one named, since other sizes may need a different cut.

• Count: 150 pieces
• Style: wrap-around
• Named fit: Farberware 4-cup percolator
• Material: unbleached paper
• Use: disposable, one brew per filter

The seller also describes the paper as free of a paper taste, which is a common promise and not something this guide can measure. If you notice any papery note in the first cup, a quick rinse of the filter under hot water before loading the basket usually clears it.

Pros:

• Wrap-around shape covers the basket sides
• Clearly names the pot it targets

Cons:

• Narrow fit for one pot size
• Unbleached paper has a tan color

It is the clearer-labeled sibling of the first pick, which names more pots but not the shape.

6. Brew Rite Wrap Around Percolator Filters (2 Packs of 55) – Best for Occasional Use

#6 Pick

Brew Rite Wrap Around Percolator Coffee Filter 55 Ct (Pack of 2)

Check Price on Amazon →

This listing from Brew Rite is two packs of 55 wrap-around percolator filters. The title does not name a pot size, so confirm the basket dimensions on the product page. Wrap-around filters are a classic format for stovetop and camp percolators, and a pack of 110 is a sensible quantity for someone who brews on weekends or trips rather than daily.

The smaller count also means less to store, and fewer leftover filters if you later change your pot.

• Count: 2 packs of 55 filters, per the title
• Style: wrap-around
• Pot size: not stated, so confirm on listing
• Material: confirm on listing
• Use: disposable

Wrap-around filters are especially handy on camp stoves, where the basket takes more knocks and grounds spill easily. Pack the filters in a zip bag with the percolator so they stay dry, and carry a spare in case wind or damp ruins a few sheets.

Pros:

• Small packs suit occasional brewers
• Wrap-around shape covers basket sides

Cons:

• Fit is not named in the title
• Smaller supply for daily use

Compared with the MIMORE pack, it has the same shape in a smaller quantity and less specific pot fit.

Specs Compared

How We Chose These

This guide compares the six listed filter packs on what a buyer can check before purchase: the stated count, the named pot models, whether the shape is a disc or a wrap-around, and the paper type. Information comes from listing titles, seller descriptions, and manufacturer product pages where a brand publishes them. We did not rank by taste, because a paper filter changes the cup only slightly compared with grind, water, and timing. Where a listing did not state a diameter or style, we say so and send you to the product page.

What to Look For

Disc Versus Wrap-Around Shape

A disc is a flat circle that lies on the basket floor, with the stem passing through a hole in the center. A wrap-around filter is a longer strip or shaped sheet that folds around the stem and lines the wall. Discs are easy to drop in and suit shallow baskets; wrap-arounds give more side coverage for deep baskets filled with coffee. Mixing them up is the most common mistake, so check which style your pot instructions call for. If the manual is lost, search the model number on the manufacturer site, where parts and accessories pages often list the recommended filter type and size. When the listing and the manufacturer disagree, trust the manufacturer, and treat a seller compatibility list as a starting point rather than a guarantee.

Measure Before You Buy

Measure the inside diameter of the basket floor with a ruler, and note the stem width. A 3.75-inch disc will not seat in a basket whose floor is much smaller or larger without folding, and a folded edge lets grounds slip under. If your manual lists a filter size, use it, and if the listing says “confirm on the manufacturer page,” follow that advice before you buy a 300-piece pack.

Perforated Paper and Flow

Perforated filters have small holes so water moves freely, which suits a percolator because the pot recycles hot water over the grounds many times. Standard drip filters are too dense and can restrict flow. Pick filters sold for percolators, not those sold for drip makers, unless the manufacturer says otherwise.

Bleached Versus Unbleached

Unbleached paper keeps its natural brown color and skips the whitening step, while white paper is bleached. Either can work well; the practical difference is appearance and personal preference. If you taste a papery note, rinse the filter lightly with hot water before filling the basket.

Storage and Handling

Filters are paper, so they pick up moisture and smells. Keep the pack closed in a dry cupboard away from the stove, and do not store it next to onions, spices, or cleaning sprays. Count out a few filters for a trip instead of carrying the whole pack, and keep them flat so the perforations and edges stay intact.

Percolator Basics That Affect Filter Choice

A percolator pushes hot water up a center tube and sprays it over the grounds in the basket, then lets it drain back into the pot to repeat the cycle. Because the same water passes through the basket again and again, fine particles have many chances to escape, which is why paper is popular. Use a coarse grind, avoid overfilling the basket, and stop the brew once the color suits you; over-percolating pulls out bitterness no filter can remove. Your manual gives the right coffee amount and time for your pot.

Worked Example: Count and Usage

If you brew one pot a day, a 150-piece pack lasts about five months and a 300-piece pack about ten months. At three weekend pots a month, a 110-filter supply lasts well over two years, so a large pack would sit unused. Buy for the pace you brew, and remember that paper absorbs odors if stored near spices or cleaning supplies.

Keeping the Percolator Itself Clean

A fresh filter only helps if the pot is clean. Rinse the basket, stem, and lid after every brew, and run a vinegar-and-water cycle or follow your manual when the pot looks dull or tastes sour. Old coffee oils turn rancid and flavor the next batch no matter which paper you choose. Dry the parts fully before storing them.

Questions

Do percolators need paper filters?

Not always. Most percolators come with a metal basket that works without paper, but paper catches fine grounds and oils, which gives a cleaner cup. Use paper if you dislike sediment at the bottom of the mug.

Can I use regular drip coffee filters in a percolator?

You can cut or fold some, but they rarely fit well, and dense paper restricts water flow. Percolator-specific filters are shaped and perforated for the job.

What grind works with a percolator and filter?

Most percolator guides recommend a coarse grind, similar to what a French press uses, because fine grounds slip past the basket holes and clog paper. Follow your pot manual for amounts and brew time.

Are unbleached filters better for taste?

Not necessarily. Some drinkers prefer them, but taste differences are small compared with grind, water, and freshness. A quick rinse with hot water helps either type.

Why does my percolator coffee still have grounds in it?

Grounds usually get through when the grind is too fine, the filter is the wrong size, or the basket is overfilled. Switch to a coarser grind, confirm the diameter or wrap-around shape, and fill the basket no more than the manual allows.

Is it safe to buy a large pack before I know the filter fits?

It is better to buy the smallest pack first. Fit varies by basket, and even listings naming your model can differ in cut. Try one sheet, make sure it seats without folding or leaving gaps, and then stock up.

Update History

• October 21, 2026 – Initial publication; product set drawn from current catalog listings.
• Check the product page for current specifications and availability before buying.

Sources

• Retailer listing titles and specification fields for each filter pack
• Manufacturer product pages, including Melitta filter product information
• Seller compatibility lists naming Farberware, Presto, Coletti, Elite Gourmet, and Moss and Stone percolators